Slab-Obsessed Scalper Only Gets 9 on Own Mortal Soul

Darwin LaPollo • November 18, 2026

As I write these words, I reflect upon my life so far. What went wrong? More importantly, who should I blame?

I’ve tried to live my life in a principled and fruitful way. I have tried to follow my passions in accordance with my morals, and I believe that I have done so admirably. So, PSA, tell me, what mark exists upon my soul to deem it unworthy of a perfect 10 score?

I suppose I should provide a bit of background.

I deal in high-value trading cards–I buy them cheap, get them professionally graded, and sell them for a lot of money. I’m a necessary and helpful member of the cardstock market, but I’ve admittedly been in a bit of a rut lately. Foil cards have been curling more, the rest of the economy has been taking hits left and right, and even I, a prominent member of the community, haven’t been able to get through the Secret Lair queues before they’re sold out. So, I decided I needed to make a bit of a bargain.

Satan and I go way back. He gets a bad rap, but he’s no different from you or me. Above all, he likes to cut a deal just as much as I do. I needed to get my hands on some valuable cards, he wanted my soul. Not a bad deal–it’s not like I’ve ever really used my soul for anything anyway. But I thought I would do The Beast the courtesy of getting my soul graded in the hopes that he’d sweeten his side of the deal as well.

Which brings us to when I sent my soul to PSA to get it in that nice protective slab with that glorious “10” signifying its mint condition. Well, it came back today, just in time for my scheduled meetup with Satan to get the deal done. I’m staring at it right now. Staring at the “9” that says that something about my soul is wrong.

Is it the centering? Is the surface of my soul scuffed or something? The only note they sent with it said, “weighed against feather on Scale, way too heavy,” as if that’s supposed to mean anything. Satan is coming, and if I don’t have a perfect soul to give him, he’s going to subject me to a lifetime of Secret Lair queues selling out just before my turn and reprints driving prices into the ground so that people who play the game can “afford it” instead of the game company catering to reasonable, rational people like me who see it not as a game but as a commodity.

Perhaps he’ll let me postpone our meeting. Then, I can find a better soul to trade him. Yes, yes, that might work. He’ll understand. Now, whose soul shall I procure, I wonder? Oh, there is that kid at the game store nearby who’s been asking after my PSA 10 Legends Nicol Bolas. That’s a fair trade, a 10 for a 10. He’d be a fool not to take it.



Darwin is a Philly-based writer, musician, and game designer who does some of those things professionally. He mostly plays Commander, Cube, and occasionally Bearbeâr, the Dandân variant he made for some reason.